Il menù

Sicilian Catering Menu & Party Trays

Handmade Sicilian trays for birthdays, BBQs, graduations, office lunches and private dinners. New York and South Florida.

Order a Tray Call (646) 210-8780

How our trays are sized

Half Tray(feeds 4-5)

Full Tray(feeds 9-10)

Numbers in parentheses like (15/30) are piece counts for half / full trays. Pies are cut into 8 slices.

Pasta al forno

Pasta & Baked Trays

Prices per tray: Half and Full.

Meat lasagna tray, La Mia Sicilia Catering

  • Baked Ziti

    Meat or spinach, topped with melted mozzarella

    GF available
    Half
    $65
    Full
    $120

  • Spaghetti San Marzano

    San Marzano tomato sauce and fresh basil

    GF available
    Half
    $60
    Full
    $110

  • Spaghetti with Meatballs

    Meatballs, tomato sauce and fresh basil

    GF available
    Half
    $70
    Full
    $130

  • Meat Lasagna

    Ground beef topped with melted mozzarella and parsley

    GF available
    Half
    $85
    Full
    $160

  • Spinach Lasagna

    With ricotta cheese and spinach

    GF available
    Half
    $80
    Full
    $150

  • Baked Anelletti

    Anelletti pasta with peas, eggplant and eggs

    GF available
    Half
    $80
    Full
    $150

  • Meat Cannelloni

    Stuffed with meat, cheese and tomato sauce

    GF available
    Half
    $85
    Full
    $160

  • Spinach Cannelloni

    Stuffed with ricotta cheese and spinach

    GF available
    Half
    $85
    Full
    $160

  • Garlic Knots

    Half
    $40
    Full
    $75

Insalate e contorni

Salads & Sides

Prices per tray: Half and Full.

Salads

  • Caesar Salad

    Half
    $55
    Full
    $100

  • Chicken Caesar Salad

    Half
    $70
    Full
    $130

  • Green Salad

    Half
    $50
    Full
    $90

  • Greek Salad

    Half
    $55
    Full
    $100

Sides

  • Homemade French Fries

    Half
    $40
    Full
    $70

  • Italian Roasted Potatoes

    Half
    $50
    Full
    $90

  • Potato Croquettes (25/50)

    Half
    $45
    Full
    $85

Rosticceria

Fried, Sliders & Rosticceria

Prices per tray: Half and Full.

Sicilian rice balls, La Mia Sicilia Catering

  • Chicken Tenders

    Half
    $70
    Full
    $130

  • Chicken Nuggets

    Half
    $60
    Full
    $110

  • Chicken Wings

    Half
    $90
    Full
    $170

  • Mozzarella Sticks (25/50)

    Half
    $50
    Full
    $90

  • Homemade Fish Sticks (25/50)

    Half
    $50
    Full
    $90

  • Mini Rice Balls (20/40)

    GF available
    Half
    $55
    Full
    $105

  • Rice Balls (15/30)

    Filled with meat, spinach or cheese

    GF available
    Half
    $80
    Full
    $155

  • Cheeseburger Sliders (15/30)

    Half
    $85
    Full
    $160

  • Chicken Sliders (15/30)

    Half
    $85
    Full
    $160

  • Italian Meatball Sliders (15/30)

    Half
    $85
    Full
    $160

  • Hot Dogs (15/30)

    Half
    $50
    Full
    $95

  • Sicilian Hot Dogs (12/24)

    Half
    $60
    Full
    $110

  • Meat Bombette (12/24)

    Half
    $80
    Full
    $150

  • Spinach Bombette (12/24)

    Half
    $75
    Full
    $140

Pizza e specialità

Pizza & Sicilian Specialties

Little Sicilian pizzas, La Mia Sicilia Catering

Pizza

  • Margherita

    San Marzano tomato sauce, mozzarella and basil

    GF available

    Ask for pricing

  • Pepperoni

    San Marzano tomato sauce, mozzarella and pepperoni

    GF available

    Ask for pricing

  • Vegetarian

    San Marzano tomato sauce, mozzarella and mixed vegetables

    GF available

    Ask for pricing

  • Cherry Tomato

    San Marzano tomato sauce, buffalo mozzarella, basil and cherry tomatoes

    GF available

    Ask for pricing

  • Prosciutto & Arugula

    Prosciutto di Parma, arugula, cherry tomato and Parmesan

    GF available

    Ask for pricing

  • Italian Sausage

    San Marzano tomato sauce, mozzarella, sausage and peppers

    GF available

    Ask for pricing

Pies & Boards

  • Sicilian Pie 8 slices

    San Marzano tomato sauce and mozzarella, thick crust

    GF available
    One size
    $45

  • Sfincione 8 slices

    Tomato, onion, anchovies, cheese, oregano and bread crumbs

    GF available
    One size
    $50

  • Zucchini Pie 8 slices

    One size
    $40

  • Focaccia

    One size
    $40

  • Charcuterie Board

    Based on selections

    Market price

GF available Gluten-free options available on request.

Chef privato

Chef Privato: We Bring the Chef to You

Homes, offices, yachts, private jets, schools and venues. Chef Piero cooks on site and serves a Sicilian meal, from an intimate table to a full room. For larger nights he brings his own waitstaff and a licensed bartender. Every experience is custom.

Plan an Event

Home

Business

Yacht

Private Jet

Schools

Private Parties

Cooking Classes

Events

Dove cuciniamo

Service areas

New York

  • New York City
  • Brooklyn
  • All of New York, out to the Hamptons

South Florida

  • Fort Lauderdale
  • Boca Raton
  • Delray Beach
  • West Palm Beach

Domande

Frequently asked questions

How many people does a tray feed?
A half tray feeds 4-5 people and a full tray feeds 9-10. For finger food, the numbers in parentheses are the piece counts for a half and a full tray. Pies are cut into 8 slices.
How far ahead should I order?
Contact us for availability.
Do you have gluten-free options?
Yes. Gluten-free options are available on request. Dishes marked GF available can be made gluten-free.
Do you deliver?
Contact us for delivery details.

Prenota

Book your private event today

(646) 210-8780
Order a Tray Request a Proposal